
I might be the minority in this, but Surfacing remains my favorite Sarah album to date. It's the album that made me a fan, and I still love it as much as the first time I heard it. In fact, I can distinctly remember thinking to myself that the album was special upon hearing the opening of "I Love You," (I'd heard "BAM" tons of times on the radio by then, so it wasn't until getting to "ILY" that the gorgeousness of what I was about to hear started to hit me) and the album has grown in my affection ever since. I know that a lot of fans consider it to be a slide into more commercial territory for Sarah, but I think there is a lot of beauty and creativity woven into those songs.